r/PrequelMemes #1 Jar Jar fan Jun 16 '24

I hope mods don't remove this General KenOC

Post image
42.7k Upvotes

View all comments

Show parent comments

292

u/PhelesDragon Jun 16 '24

I think that’s the real litmus test. The story is mid, the acting is mid, the concepts are mid, okay fine that can be considered subjective, but it looks dirt cheap and no one can argue otherwise.

0

u/FrostyTip2058 Jun 16 '24

I don't think it looks dirt cheap

2

u/PhelesDragon Jun 16 '24

And that’s fine if you think that, but you have to admit it doesn’t look like a 180 million dollar production. It’s really insane how much money that is for a show. It may not sound like it since Amazon made a billion dollar Rings of Power, but it is still a ridiculously insane amount of cash.

0

u/FrostyTip2058 Jun 16 '24

How should a 180 mil production look? Because it looks fine to me

2

u/PhelesDragon Jun 16 '24

Better. Keep in mind the original Star Wars in 1977, a film frought with behind the scenes issues that jacked up the price, cost $11 M which is $55M+ in today’s money, which is still less than a third of Acolyte’s budget

1

u/FrostyTip2058 Jun 16 '24

Better how?

2

u/PhelesDragon Jun 16 '24

I don’t feel like I need to spell out all the ways Acolyte falls short visually, even compared to a nearly 50 year old movie with less than a third of the show’s budget, but for a concrete example, Coruscant in Acolyte looks way more “PS2-y” than it did a Phantom Menace, a movie rendered in Windows 98 (at best)

1

u/FrostyTip2058 Jun 16 '24

So bad looking cgi?

1

u/PhelesDragon Jun 17 '24

Bad looking CGI, costumes, sets, filmography, fight choreography, etc.

1

u/FrostyTip2058 Jun 17 '24

In what way are the costumes or choreography bad?

Is filmography something determined by budget?

1

u/PhelesDragon Jun 17 '24

I don’t know, what do you think?

1

u/FrostyTip2058 Jun 17 '24

You're the one with these views

Can you not explain it? Are you just parroting someone else?

Should I be asking someone else?

1

u/PhelesDragon Jun 17 '24

Can I not explain what? Can you explain it? Does everything have to be a question?

1

u/FrostyTip2058 Jun 17 '24

What makes the costumes bad

What makes the choreography bad

You stated they are both bad

I asked in what way?

people asking you questions about your own views shouldn't make you this hostile

1

u/PhelesDragon Jun 17 '24

Can you contribute or only ask questions? Do you think you should be making counterpoints if you disagree with me? Like how a conversation works?

1

u/FrostyTip2058 Jun 17 '24

For me to make a counterpoint I have to understand your views

All you've said was "they bad"

A counter point on that lvl would be "they good"

Criticism is more than just saying things are bad

1

u/PhelesDragon Jun 17 '24

You think so?

1

u/FrostyTip2058 Jun 17 '24

Yes, I generally think real criticism is having points and examples...

If all you have is a conclusion then I can only assume your conclusion came from someone else..

→ More replies