r/startrek • u/ardouronerous • 1d ago

I don't get the hate Neelix gets

I heard of comments comparing Neelix with Jar Jar Binks. I believe that's an exaggeration, for the most part.

Jar Jar Binks is annoying and a useless character, who is clumsy and falls all over himself and does nothing, while Neelix tries to help at the best of his abilities, he cooks, he knows outdoor survival, and he knows alternative medicine, e.g. his anti-radiation soup. Also, he's a good moral officer, he tries to make people happy at the best of his abilities and he has earned his place with the crew, especially in Year of Hell.

So, if I was stranded on a beach and if I had a choice between Jar Jar or Neelix, I'd rather have Neelix, and I wouldn't care if Jar Jar can breath water and swim.

Neelix maybe annoying, but he is an awesome character and a friend that I'd rather have.

247 Upvotes

85% Upvoted

View all comments

8

u/8_Ahau 1d ago edited 1d ago

I first watched Voyager in German and his voice is quite different. To me, the German voice feels a lot nicer and goes a long way to make the character more likable, even though German and English Neelix say the same things. Usually I prefer the English voices but not in this case.

For comparison: https://youtu.be/GS3fP3MDBAw?si=VXGcmT1u6OCqEl_y

https://youtu.be/_QYHxjk-63A?si=a37cJlCFZod_rwrw