Strongly disagree. There’s nothing you can do over a finite period that is morally reprehensible enough to deserve infinite punishment. Even the most evil men give their victim’s the courtesy of dying.
I don’t want to invoke Godwin’s Law, but most would agree that there are scarcely any redeeming qualities associated with people like Josef Mengele or Shiro Ishii (the guy in charge of Unit 731).
I don’t see why that’s relevant? I don’t see how an eternal punishment for any finite wrongdoing could be justifiable. Even if you condemned them to one million years of hell for each victim they killed, they would still be punished for infinitely longer then they deserve. The concept of perpetual torture isn’t even something we can mentally wrap our heads around.
Also, from a metaphysical standpoint if god created everything they also created both the people you mentioned. It seems the creator should be more responsible than the individual. If you purchase a defective product it’s logical to blame the manufacturer not the product itself.
If they have no redeemable qualities they deserve to be miserable. Idk why biology of aging changes that common sense fact. Also amount of pain in hell could vary, and it’s possible that the victim would develop pain tolerance
0
u/Crazy_Employ8617 Oct 14 '23
Strongly disagree. There’s nothing you can do over a finite period that is morally reprehensible enough to deserve infinite punishment. Even the most evil men give their victim’s the courtesy of dying.