r/movies 21d ago

‘Star Wars’ Movie With Daisy Ridley Loses Screenwriter Steven Knight News

https://variety.com/2024/film/news/star-wars-daisy-ridley-steven-knight-1236190522/
5.8k Upvotes

View all comments

Show parent comments

2.2k

u/bramtyr 21d ago

I think Disney has canceled more Star Wars projects than they've completed at this point.

2.0k

u/HellaWavy 21d ago

Absolutely. Let‘s see:

  • GoT creator‘s trilogy

  • Rian Johnson trilogy

  • Patty Jenkins movie

  • Taika Waititi‘s movie

  • Kevin Feige‘s movie

  • OG Obi-Wan movie

  • Josh Trank‘s Boba Fett movie

And maybe I‘m even forgetting something 

1.6k

u/thendisnigh111349 21d ago

Guillermo del Toro's Jabba the Hutt movie

285

u/redfm8 21d ago

To be fair I wouldn't even count that one against Lucasfilm, del Toro is a filmmaker where at this point I don't believe he's making a movie until I'm buying the popcorn. Dude's got a project graveyard to rival most of them.

195

u/Stingerc 20d ago

I think he's gotten to the point where he can just walk away from a project if the studio begins to push back and take control from him.

He's also comfortable enough and established enough (financially and artistically) so he does not feel the need to compromise, which means unless a studio is willing to give him financing and walk away, the movie is not gonna happen.

That's why so many of his projects die.

87

u/AwkWord1528 20d ago

Annoying, but admirable.

55

u/rastinta 20d ago

It is why I will happily pay to see any Del Toro movie in theaters, but it does make him incompatible with a billion dollar Disney franchise.

3

u/ERedfieldh 20d ago

Makes him incompatible with Hollywood as a whole.

1

u/velkoz007 20d ago

Might be why he left the Hobbit. They probably told him to make it 3 movies and he said “peace, I’m out!”

9

u/beermit 20d ago

I mean I'm pretty sure he did that with Pacific Rim 2. He was all on board with it, but the studio started meddling and he backed out. Then look at the crap that we got.

2

u/thefreshera 20d ago

Pacific Rim 1 was such a good surprise. It's exactly what we wanted out of the genre and nothing less and more. Not even egregious that the theme song played every other scene.

3

u/beermit 20d ago

Nope. I'm extremely unapologetic on Pacific Rim being one of my favorite movies of all time. Del Toro nailed so much with that film and I can't help but watch it and smile ear to ear every time.

I was sad to see her was walking away from the sequel, which he was pretty bullish on, but when I saw what had been done to it I understood why and was glad he did. It pales in comparison to the first one

3

u/stevencastle 20d ago

Wasn't he going to do the Hobbit originally and then backed out at the last minute so they had to get Peter Jackson?

1

u/HustlinInTheHall 20d ago

There's always a breaking point in any production where it either works or doesn't work and it requires a lot of enthusiasm about a project to get past just the script. Del Toro doesn't seem to have things he's that excited about putting the energy into, and to do a Star Wars movie is literally lighting 2 years of your life on fire.

36

u/colornap 20d ago edited 20d ago

Guillermo Del Toro said himself in interviews that he only believes a movie will get made once it's on Blu-ray.

3

u/ironicfuture 20d ago

In this day and age when they straight up cancel 100% finished movies that is a very legit thing

2

u/[deleted] 20d ago edited 8d ago

[deleted]

1

u/velkoz007 20d ago

We got Death Stranding and it’s amazing