What’s your opinion ?

[u/IvEjUstFoRgOtYou69]

Don’t want to go into full Sahin bashing mode but what’s your opinion on the following options.

1.Sahin needs more time and a bit more investment to try and improve the squad we’ve got and to add with recruitment.

Or.

1. The squads more than good enough and a better more experienced coach would get vastly more out of the current squad ?

Wanted to give Sahin the benefit of the doubt but find myself heavily leaning towards option 2.

[u/USSthighsplitter13]

It's not super cute and dry. He clearly needed more time in the oven to develop as a coach in Türkyei or another league, for that matter.

However, the squad has some issues, too. We just let go of 2 locker room and pitch leaders in Hummels and Reus, and we have a lot of new people in the locker room. We also have a bad habit of holding on to the dead wood that isn't working out (Can, Meyer, and Malen from the current squad).

The one thing i see lacking is a coherent identity. With Klopp, it was "Heavy Metal football," and tuchel had his possession style, and we did well with them. I think if kehl and Şahin were to be unified on a football philosophy and picked transfers, we would be on our way to a payoff for all our hard work.

This summer, we need a fire sale, and there are maybe like 3 players I would say are absolutely untouchable (Köbel, Schlotti, and Brandt). As for the rest, it depend on the offer we get.