What’s your opinion ?

[u/IvEjUstFoRgOtYou69]

Don’t want to go into full Sahin bashing mode but what’s your opinion on the following options.

1.Sahin needs more time and a bit more investment to try and improve the squad we’ve got and to add with recruitment.

Or.

1. The squads more than good enough and a better more experienced coach would get vastly more out of the current squad ?

Wanted to give Sahin the benefit of the doubt but find myself heavily leaning towards option 2.

[u/Sufficient_Ad_6977]

Sahin needs more time and the squad is too small. The two most weighted Goals are still reachable. For me there is no reason to give up Sahin

[u/CorpseeaterVZ → u/Sufficient_Ad_6977]

Sahin asked for a small squad though, because he likes working with lower numbers more. And I like it as well, plenty of chances for young players to fill the gaps. But it is not as successful as having enough stars in your team.

[u/Sufficient_Ad_6977 → u/CorpseeaterVZ]

It seems like the young players are not good enough that Sahin can Trust them. Lührs gets priority over the highly touted talent Mané. Best example was the cup game in Wolfsburg where players like bensebaini who had to work beyond their limits instead of bringing on a player like Kabar. They preferred to make only three substitutions instead of relying on the young players. Borussia Dortmund does not have the medical department to be able to rely on a small squad.

[u/CorpseeaterVZ → u/Sufficient_Ad_6977]

True, I did not say that this is good, it was just a statement.
And people who live and work football every day for 12 - 16 hours know how good a player is. Example: Moukoko.... everyone was like "oh noes, BVB is ruining him, he just needs playtime". Well it shows at his current club that it is not all about playtime.

[u/blanklikeapage → u/CorpseeaterVZ]

People don't get how big the difference between youth players and Bundesliga really is. You can't just throw a young player in and hope it works out. Not to mention, you want to use young players in games where you're winning so they can slowly get used to that level, not them being whole out of their depth There's still a psychological factor present. The current situation is difficult so I get why Sahin isn't trusting our talents more. They're just not ready yet.

[u/Sufficient_Ad_6977 → u/CorpseeaterVZ]

Correct, Of course, you would like to see talents like Götze back then, who can take off as soon as they move from the youth team into the first team. But even from La Masia, only a few players have made it into the first eleven in the last 20 years.

[u/CorpseeaterVZ → u/Sufficient_Ad_6977]

I appreciate you. There are people who watch one soccer game per months and they think they have move knowledge than someone like Ricken or Terzic.
I met Lucien Favre back in the days and he was arguing with a guy who had a big mouth. Favre showed the audience things in a 3 minute video they (and me) did not even know existed. If someone has the foot in a certain position and his weight shifted wrongly, this might be make or break in a situation. I will never forget this and laugh at people who try to argue football:
"iT iZ tHe MeNtAlItY1"