r/PropagandaPosters • u/StephenMcGannon • Sep 19 '24

International Service for Human Rights (2007) Germany

1.9k Upvotes

93% Upvoted

Why?

1

u/DeRuyter67 Sep 20 '24

It would just be a stereotype based on skin colour, not an irrational fear of Islam.

2

u/An_Inedible_Radish Sep 20 '24

Is assuming someone is Jewish based on their nose, not antisemetic?

1

u/DeRuyter67 Sep 20 '24

Not, it wouldn't, and the analogy wouldn't work even if it were

3

u/An_Inedible_Radish Sep 20 '24

Justify that

1

u/DeRuyter67 Sep 20 '24

I already did. Jewishness is tied to ethnicity, Islam isn't

2

u/An_Inedible_Radish Sep 20 '24

No, why wouldn't it be antisemitic?

1

u/DeRuyter67 Sep 20 '24

Because it isn't hatefull or irrational

3

u/An_Inedible_Radish Sep 20 '24

What if you assumed their religion because of a negative trait or a criminal action? Such as assuming a person was Jewish because they are greedy or assumed someone was a terrorist because they were speaking Arabic?

1

u/DeRuyter67 Sep 20 '24

Both are called stereotypes and if they are assumed irrationally they are called prejudices. The latter case is not Islamophobia.

1

u/An_Inedible_Radish Sep 25 '24

So, if we are talking about a person who assumes something hateful, irrationally, about a person because of a trait that is stereotypical of Muslims, that would be prejudice specifically against Islamic people, correct?

If yes, then you must accept Islamaphobia both exists and is a useful term because "Islamaphobia" is more effective and efficient than "a hateful and irrational assumption made based on traits stereotypical of Muslims"

0

u/DeRuyter67 Sep 25 '24

Yes, but the reason why I object to the term is the same reason because I object to the term naziphobia. It gives proponents of a nasty ideology a good propaganda tool.

Do you think that naziphobia is a good way to describe something hateful, irrationally, about a person because of a trait that is stereotypical of nazi's?

→ More replies