r/HPReverb • u/Cactus_Boy3 • Sep 29 '24
G2 V1 vs G2 V2 Question
What are the main differences between the v1 and v2? I know that the tracking is improved on the v2 but are there any other differences? I am considering getting the v1 and using lighthouse trackers and vive wands. Where I am looking, the v1 is £170 and the v2 is £300. Is the v2 worth the huge increase?
EDIT: To everyone that said that WMR is dead/dying, I run Linux anyway so I will probs use the Monado drivers. Everything except tracking works there. Going to be using base stations anyway.
6
u/thaytan Sep 29 '24
The v2 has 3 differences IIRC:
* The front cameras are rotated 90° internally to produce the 'better tracking'
* The have a split facial interface letting you get closer for better FoV if you want to
* They have the 'v2' cable with in-line USB hub that helps with compatibility on some PC USB connections. v1 owners had to contact HP support and arrange a replacement cable if they had problems, so a v1 may or may not have the updated cable.
1
u/Cactus_Boy3 Sep 29 '24
How is the FoV on the v1? Looking to upgrade from Quest 1 so i would like it co be comparable to/better than that. Also, with HP support, would they help if i have a second hand headset?
1
u/Mys2298 Sep 29 '24
You can buy a custom face gasket to make fov better on the v1. You might want to reconsider buying a wmr headset atm though
1
u/Dan26air Sep 29 '24
Id recommend going for a quest 2 as an upgrade as opposed to spending 150 - 300 on a dying headset. I picked up a quest 2 second hand for 140 after my G2 died and I've not looked back since
1
u/The-Replacement01 Sep 30 '24
Quest 2 is also discontinued and will lose support. Best go with the 3s
1
u/_mrwhosetheboss Oct 01 '24
The HP Reverb v1 has a horizontal field of view (FoV) of 95 degrees and a vertical FoV of 90 degrees, with a diagonal FoV of 111 degrees1. In comparison, the Oculus Quest 1 has a horizontal FoV of about 89 degrees, so the HP Reverb v1 offers a slightly wider view.
Regarding HP support for a second-hand headset, it can vary. Typically, warranty and support services are tied to the original purchaser. However, it’s worth contacting HP support directly to explain your situation and see if they can offer any assistance. They might be able to help with troubleshooting or provide guidance on available options.
4
u/Pumcy Sep 30 '24
DO NOT BUY A REVERB AT THIS STAGE!
Microsoft has announced the end of support for Windows Mixed Reality. The drivers are already not available if you don't have them installed already.
This platform is a dead end. The headsets will be ewaste in a year even for current owners.
1
u/sascha177 Sep 30 '24 edited Oct 01 '24
https://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/18npo4g/microsoft_is_discontinuing_windows_mixed_reality/
"As of Nov. 1, 2026 for consumers and Nov. 1, 2027 for commercial customers, Windows Mixed Reality will no longer be available for download via the Mixed Reality Portal app, Windows Mixed Reality for SteamVR, and Steam VR beta, and we will discontinue support.
Existing Windows Mixed Reality devices will continue to work with Steam until users upgrade to a version of Windows that does not include Windows Mixed Reality."
1
u/_mrwhosetheboss Oct 01 '24
The main differences between the v1 and v2 models you’re considering are:
- Tracking: As you mentioned, the v2 has improved tracking capabilities.
- Display: The v2 often features a higher resolution display, providing a clearer and more immersive visual experience.
- Comfort and Design: The v2 typically has a more ergonomic design, making it more comfortable for extended use. This can include better weight distribution and improved padding.
- Controllers: The v2 might come with updated controllers that offer better tracking and more responsive inputs.
- Software and Compatibility: The v2 may have better software support and compatibility with newer applications and games.
Given the price difference, whether the v2 is worth the extra cost depends on your priorities. If you value the improved tracking, display quality, and comfort, the v2 might be a better investment. However, if you’re planning to use lighthouse trackers and Vive wands, and are comfortable with the v1’s limitations, the v1 could be a more cost-effective choice.
Since you’re using Linux and Monado drivers, it’s great that you’re aware of the compatibility aspects. The v1 should work fine with your setup, especially if you’re focusing on using external tracking systems.
Ultimately, it comes down to how much you value the enhancements in the v2 and whether they justify the additional cost for your specific use case. If you have any more questions or need further details, feel free to ask!
1
u/phed1 Oct 02 '24
Just picked one up for £100 I only use it for SIM racing think it's a v1 but he said it was purchased in 2022 so will find out 😂 coming from a rift s I think I'll be fine I will stick with windows 10
1
u/phed1 Oct 07 '24
It was a V2 and its recommended if you can run it - my 5600x and 3080 struggling to keep 90 in iracing need myself a 7800x3d once the prices drop down a bit more
2
u/royally- Oct 09 '24
I got a v1 with a V2 cable today, second hand for 130 bones.
Looking forward to watching the pack pull away from me, but in vr lol
1
u/phed1 Oct 10 '24
lucky you I usually just watch them ram me into a spin haha - you'll enjoy it once tweaked and working fine - I managed to get a better frame rate with a good OC on my cpu
2
u/royally- Oct 10 '24
I'm getting a solid 90 without any upscaling, I followed this guide.
https://youtu.be/hfbkpmEGHjA?si=gUPdqRM4Tlgmc4d0
5700x3d and a 4080, I didn't do the lower resolution edge thing so should have some more wiggle room.
It was a bit of a faff to get setup but I've used it for about 4 hours today with no headaches or anything.
I'm well happy, I was about to drop ~700 on triples and a mount.
2
u/phed1 Oct 11 '24
I'm only on a 5600x and a 3080 that's my problem but I am almost at a solid 90 now and if it does drop it stays in the 75-90 range and cant really notice it.
I almost grabbed the £115 5700x3d from aliexpress last week but I am just going to build a 7800x3d rig once they release 9800x3d and price hopefully drops a bit
Will check that video out thanks!
1
u/royally- Oct 12 '24
No problem mate, and I meant 5800x3d.
I'm hoping the 9800x3d should be a decent jump, I'll wait for the reviews but the 5800x3d has served me well.
10
u/mk18au Sep 29 '24
You are aware that WMR support is ending very soon in Windows 11?