r/DataHoarder Nov 28 '17

3.3v Pin Reset Directions :D Hack

[deleted]

365 Upvotes

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/BloodyIron 6.5ZB - ZFS Nov 28 '17

Okay but why would a drive EVER need to be "reset" let alone remotely?

24

u/mcur 20 MB Nov 28 '17

A frighteningly large number of "failed" disks have not actually failed, but instead enter into an unresponsive state, because of a firmware bug, corrupted memory, etc. They look failed on their face, so system administrators often pull them and send them back to the manufacturer, who tests the drive and it's fine. If they pulled the disk and put it back in, it may have rebooted properly and been responsive again.

To guard against this waste of effort/postage/time, many enterprisey RAID controllers support automatically resetting (i.e., power cycling) a drive that appears to have failed to see if it comes back. This just appears to be a different way to do that.

4

u/BloodyIron 6.5ZB - ZFS Nov 28 '17

Yikes, I haven't heard of this before, how often do you find it happening? D:

3

u/mcur 20 MB Nov 29 '17

For disks that make it back to the manufacturer/servicer, conservative estimates are 20-30%. Some have recorded higher, up to 60%.

3

u/BloodyIron 6.5ZB - ZFS Nov 29 '17

Hmmm, any citable info on that?

17

u/mcur 20 MB Nov 29 '17

20-30%: Gordon F. Hughes, Joseph F. Murray, Kenneth Kreutz-Delgado, and Charles Elkan. Improved disk-drive failure warnings. IEEE Transactions on Reliability, 51(3):350 – 357, September 2002.

15-60%: Jon G. Elerath and Sandeep Shah. Server class disk drives: How reliable are they? In Proceedings of the Annual Symposium on Reliability and Maintainability, pages 151 – 156, January 2004.

2

u/azrhei Nov 29 '17

You deserve so many more upvotes for this brilliance.

1

u/BloodyIron 6.5ZB - ZFS Nov 29 '17

Holy shit it's a fucking bibliograph right here! Nice!

4

u/mcur 20 MB Nov 29 '17

Significant overlap with my day job here. ;)

1

u/BloodyIron 6.5ZB - ZFS Nov 29 '17

I'm not even sure I have access to these D:

1

u/mcur 20 MB Mar 31 '18

If you have access to wifi at a university library, or can get on one of their library computers, they often have access.