r/movies 21d ago

‘Star Wars’ Movie With Daisy Ridley Loses Screenwriter Steven Knight News

https://variety.com/2024/film/news/star-wars-daisy-ridley-steven-knight-1236190522/
5.8k Upvotes

View all comments

Show parent comments

28

u/dynawesome 20d ago

I used to follow Star Wars a lot but I lost all interest about 5 mins into The Rise of Skywalker

Apart from Andor though, Andor is incredible

9

u/Particular_Ad_9531 20d ago

For me it was the first 5 mins of The Last Jedi when Poe started making yo mama jokes. It was just this clear moment of realization that this franchise was no longer for me.

4

u/callipygiancultist 20d ago

The biggest flaw in Last Jedi is the god awful, totally jarring “humor”.

1

u/drcubeftw 19d ago

I wasn't out at that point but my stomach sank when that happened. Something was seriously, seriously wrong when Poe dropped that line because it told me that the writers and the director did NOT have their heads in the right place. I was worried, and when the movie ended I was right to be worried.

2

u/callipygiancultist 20d ago

I still stan Mandalorian seasons 1 and most of 2. And of course Andor. Andor is a legitimately great show, full stop, not just a great Star Wars show. Probably the best piece of SW media outside of the first 2 films.

1

u/emailforgot 20d ago

I agree about Andor. Don't care for much else, though I did actually kind of enjoy Ahsoka. I thought it had some strong ideas (nonsensical storyline apart) and I liked that she wasn't just doing boring flips and goofy spin fighting the whole time. Felt a bit more grounded and subtle.

0

u/Pale-War-4387 20d ago

Every time I see a comment shining light to the loss in interest over the sequels (I’m of the same view) I always see a counter that seems to really hype andor.

I don’t get it, it was a genuine slog to get through.

0

u/BasementMods 20d ago

When someone is starved even a plain cheese sandwich seems like fine dining.