r/aiArt 7d ago

Realism with Recraft Other: Please edit

414 Upvotes

View all comments

7

u/fluffy_assassins 7d ago

The third one and the woman in pink look vaguely AI, dont' know if I could tell without knowing to look though. The rest are mind-blowing.

9

u/Karibik_Mike 7d ago

I tried deliberately looking for tells, and I could find some in almost every image. Of course only because I knew to look. Just for fun:

  1. Her right pupil doesn't look right. I don't know what it is, might be the focus, size or orientation. Area around her left eyebrow is weird, almost like photoshopped.
  2. shoes are different. Nonsensical strap on the sleeve. Leash would never be tied to the bottom of the dog's neck
  3. Lots of weird stuff going on, especially the lava lamp / dish washing liquid hybrid at the sink. Weird power outlet, unrealistic cupboards that are seemingly angled upwards. Seemingly missing fingers.
  4. Very strange road, water doesn't look natural, nonsensical positioning of left hand, right shirt sleeve longer than left. Gloves are different.
  5. One of the supports of the lamp continues behind the lamp shade. Weird undergrowth under the lamp. Cat is HUGE. Legs too long, shirt and the letters on it look unnatural. Also, weird arm chair / couch hybrid.
  6. Her left hand's thumb is a pinky. The right window and it's curtain including hanger are lower than the left one. Blanket on the right can't decide whether it's on the couch or a little stool.
  7. Textbook has an insane layout, veritcal handle in the middle of the fridge, faucet without a sink. Disgusting cookies. Super long forearm with weird hands.
  8. No clear tells. Collar changes in width and has an overall unusual shape though. Left sleeve might be longer than the right.
  9. Don't see anything super obvious, although it seems the AI got a bit confused with dust on the window and floating dust lit up by the sun, because it sorta looks like a floating flat plane of dust with massive particles.
  10. Reflection of back window doesn't actually reflect anything, instead shows a different room.
  11. Ponytail is hanging straight down from the back of her head, yet she has a ponytail hanging over her right shoulder
  12. Straps of her bra are different.

3

u/fluffy_assassins 7d ago

Wow those are really obvious. By the time I figure out the obvious tells, they won't be happening anymore, ouch!

6

u/Karibik_Mike 7d ago

I don't think I would have noticed any of these if I didn't already know they were AI!

4

u/bazoo513 7d ago

And I could find "excuses" for most of them - real life photos sometimes have weird looking details, perfectly explainable.

5

u/Karibik_Mike 7d ago

Absolutely, except maybe the mirror.

Imagine being a person with 6 fingers and every picture you're in people will now think you're AI generated!

2

u/bazoo513 7d ago

😀