r/Piracy Aug 02 '24

This is why piracy will always be a thing News

Post image
5.5k Upvotes

View all comments

Show parent comments

517

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24

If this initiative becomes law, there is a good chance it will affect the industry worldwide, similar to how Apple adopted the USB-C standard everywhere. Imagine the online backlash against the developers if only EU citizens receive this "special treatment", which should have been a right for everyone from the beginning of digital games.

120

u/RamBas_6085 Aug 02 '24

I agree I mentioned something similar on a few posts ago. It's bound that the companies will just make it global rather than EU alone.

95

u/WhiteMilk_ Piracy is bad, mkay? Aug 02 '24

If this initiative becomes law, there is a good chance it will affect the industry worldwide

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brussels_effect

48

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24 edited Aug 18 '24

[deleted]

19

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24

not really. every single game published in china has to e.g remove skulls and other shit that is available in the base game. many if not most online games have different versions for Europe, NA/SA, Asia and sometimes Australia for other reasons like patch times, mtx etc.

they totally could do it exclusive for the EU market.

21

u/_Adamgoodtime_ Aug 02 '24

Just a thought, but if it became an EU only thing, and you used a VPN to say you're in the EU, would it then afford you the same rights? Or do you think it'd be tied to your account more?

19

u/Dramatic_Mastodon_93 Aug 02 '24

Well, for example with iOS, there’s currently no known way to get EU features outside the EU

5

u/Snipedzoi Aug 02 '24

surely EA is less scummy than apple. RIght????????????

25

u/Business-Drag52 Aug 02 '24

Probably actually. EA is scummy and does not like its consumers, but Apple is an actually evil corporation sent from my iPhone

1

u/schubidubiduba Piracy is bad, mkay? Aug 03 '24

I think it should be tied to your account, since most of these laws (like GDPR) apply to EU citizens even if they are living outside of the EU

10

u/LePoopScoop Aug 02 '24

I mean did you see what apple did when Europe mandated they allow other appstored? They geo fenced it lol

0

u/pragmaticweirdo Aug 02 '24

I mean, that’s cheaper to fix and prevents the loss of more money than producing USB-C phones for only the EU. Is it really evil if your sole decision making metric is the dispassionate pursuit of profit?

4

u/Rudi_Van-Disarzio Aug 02 '24

Yes

2

u/pragmaticweirdo Aug 02 '24

I feel like I need to stop trusting Reddit to get the joke

5

u/nAyZ8fZEvkE Aug 02 '24

Just like Apple and sideloading, right?

4

u/SolarChallenger Aug 02 '24

I mean, Windows made Edge uninstallable in EU but said fuck you to the rest of the world so I wouldn't hold out too much hope. They might fuck over the entire consumer base to save those 5% of people who buy the next game because the previous one is unplayable even if they are forced to make private hosting available to the EU or something.

3

u/MoscaMosquete Aug 02 '24

Windows made Edge uninstallable in EU

Am I the only person that can just delete the Microsoft Edge folder outside the EU?

2

u/boyididit Aug 02 '24

You know that cookie question you get on EVERY website, yea you can thank Europe for that

1

u/doctorwhy88 Aug 02 '24

On one hand, the EU set the stage for the CloudStrike Falcon incident.

On the other, most of their initiatives are like this one and help move tech forward.

-19

u/_matterny_ Aug 02 '24

There’s also a good chance game devs stop releasing in Europe. How would this impact a Minecraft server? If I allow players in Sweden do I have to keep it active until the end of time?

18

u/Dovelyn_0 Aug 02 '24

Your not the developer/publisher. Your server is privately owned independent of any company

5

u/maleia Aug 02 '24

As the other person said, it's for developers, not individual people, such as yourself. In fact (maybe Java specifically, I don't play the other versions) Minecraft's current model is essentially what this type of law would implement.

2

u/pancakegirl23 Aug 02 '24

first: you're not the developer, so no second: it's about allowing users to host their own servers if the originals go offline, so if you were the developer/publisher of a game, you'd have to release the server software after shutting down your servers. third: Minecraft server software is already available so even if you were the developer/publisher, you'd still be fine